Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Mike Mathers

State Farm® Insurance Agent Mike Mathers

4.9 out of 5 average rating (55 reviews)

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.

Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Chris Mayo

September 25, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Chris Mayo
"No notes, best agent ever."

Asi Ohio

September 22, 2023

1  out of  5 rating by Asi Ohio
"I had a policy written by Mike Mathers in Worthington, Ohio. A tenant backed a moving truck into a house I rent to them. State Farm did a "virtual" estimate for $1,521.08. The State Farm preferred provider submitted an estimate of $5,700+ to do the repair. State Farm said that was below my $6,000 deductible. Several months later I found the tenant's State Farm policy ALSO WRITTEN BY MIKE MATHERS. All that time MIKE MATHERS denied knowing anything about a policy he had written. Today a State Farm supervisor, Tamille Snow, tried to question MIKE MATHERS about the lies told to me. He denied to give her any information. One must wonder WHY THE LIES AND DENIALS?"


September 16, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by KEVIN IM
"Thank you for your find a good deal for my car insurance like state farm....again thanks...Mike mathers..."

Gloriya Sinelnik

June 1, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Gloriya Sinelnik
"With already dealing with the hassle of moving from one state to another, Mike really made the car insurance transfer process very easy for me. He was prompt and answered all my questions."

Bobbi Wright

April 26, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Bobbi Wright
"Always there when I need them..."

Noble apa

April 11, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Noble apa
"They really did make sure I got the best deal and I have all the places I checked they really were just great and the customer service was phenomenal"

Lender Lujano

March 22, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Lender Lujano
"Excellent service!"

Kyle Brown

March 14, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Kyle Brown
"Responsive, Thorough, and Professional Agency. Wished we switched sooner!"

Rebecca J. Dailey

February 14, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Rebecca J. Dailey
"I am very pleased with Ann’s help as I switched my policies to State Farm. She gave me lots of attention and I feel that I could call her with any questions or concerns."

caspercat kthxbai

February 14, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by caspercat kthxbai
"Wonderful to work with. Ann Lathey has been very helpful."

dan mathers

February 14, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by dan mathers
"Super great service and people! And to top it off I saved a ton of money by switching from Allstate insurance. They also always answer the phone when I have questions or concerns."

Georgia Messer

February 1, 2023

5  out of  5 rating by Georgia Messer
"I had a bad experience with State Farm 9 years ago. It wasn't the company, it was the agent/broker. Because of Mike Mathers (listening, understanding my concerns, explaining things) I am reformed. I just switched my auto and homeowners back to State Farm. Believe it or not I am excited! Thank you Mike!!!!!"

Sara Stricklen

December 20, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Sara Stricklen
"Ann Lathey of Mike Mathers State Farm Insurance was able to save us a considerable amount of money by helping us switch our home and auto insurance to State Farm. Thank you, Ann, for the prompt and professional service."

Wendy Putka

December 6, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Wendy Putka
"Excellent, caring staff who are helpful. I appreciate the way they relate to me and my family."

Kathleen C. Pyers

October 12, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Kathleen C. Pyers
"After my agent retired, Mike took over and I Have nothing but good to say about the whole office staff."

Gary Wapinski

September 6, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Gary Wapinski
"This office is nothing but awesome people whom you can actually trust to help you."

brian shaffer

August 23, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by brian shaffer
"They handle my claim in a timely manner very professional."

Lauren Oertel

July 19, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Lauren Oertel
"Mike is wonderful!! Extremely helpful and always a great communicator. Made us feel heard and supported when trying to figure out life insurance. Shout out to Justin too! Always such a treat to be helped by him as well :)"

Lori Wilson

June 29, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Lori Wilson
"Amazing service!! Most pleasant experience with an insurance company ever."

Kristin Oimas

May 17, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Kristin Oimas
"Mike is so knowledgeable and extremely helpful. He took the time to explain every detail, made sure that our coverage amounts made sense and ensured that transferring to State Farm was extremely easy. He gave us more coverage in areas that we didn’t know we didn’t have any/or enough and saved us money! We are extremely satisfied with the service that he has provided. 100% recommend Mike Mathers!"

Brainstorm Media

March 29, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Brainstorm Media
"Wanted to say how pleased we have been to work with Justin Day at Mike Mathers' office. Justin has always responded quickly to any needs we have and he is the reason we have stayed with State Farm all these years."

Kimberly Skeie

March 25, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Kimberly Skeie
"Great customer service! I highly recommend this agent and those under him. We work with Justin and he is amazing!"

Reins Robertson

March 15, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by Reins Robertson
"Justin and Mike will do you right! I love Justin because he'll pick up the phone when I call; conversely, he calls me for friendly reminders when life happens and I get we all do. Thanks guys!"

VW Ley

March 3, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by VW Ley
"We have been State Farm clients for over 20 years. Working with Mike Mathers and his team has been great. Excellent communication and support when it’s needed."


February 22, 2022

5  out of  5 rating by B C
"Saved me significant money even after 30 years with a competitor. More importantly, I have total confidence in the level of service I’ll receive should I need support on an issue. I know the owner personally and am very familiar with his work ethic. A win-win for me!"